Ontario/Quebec Business Trends
Regarding U.S. Tariffs, Canada May Capture Opportunity By Having More Domestic Wood For Some Home Construction

By Richard Lipman
Guest Writer
Big picture trade issues continue to cause concern and uncertainty across the softwood lumber industry in Canada, with many notable developments in recent weeks. The tariff fallout is hitting the Canadian forest sector hard and the government is responding as it sees best to deal with the impacts. As the fall season rolls out, Natural Resources Canada price data shows the current price for eastern SPF 2×4 at $570 (Canadian) and the 4-week average price at $578. The 52-week average price is sitting at $565.
Canada and the U.S. continued trade negotiations towards the mid-August deadline for the new round of U.S. tariffs on Canadian exports, levies of 50 percent on a variety of products. There were reports that the Section 232 tariffs on lumber were among the issues that remained to be resolved before an overall trade deal could be reached. These Section 232 tariffs stack on top of the pre-existing countervailing and anti-dumping tariffs. The implementation of the 50 percent tariffs was delayed by three days, as a deal was reported to be imminent, but ultimately it did not materialize so the tariffs were applied. In early September, Canada imposed retaliatory tariffs in response.
The Forest Products Association of Canada (FPAC) indicated it was deeply disappointed that the new 50 percent U.S. tariffs are now impacting a broad range of Canadian forest products, following the collapse in the Canada US trade negotiations. “Unfortunately with the introduction of new Section 338 tariffs, in addition to existing softwood lumber duties and Section 232 tariffs, Canada’s forest sector is among the hardest hit in the country. We must move swiftly to protect Canadian forest sector employees, businesses and communities,” said Derek Nighbor, President and CEO of FPAC. The association called for immediate action in four areas. The first was for timely, practical and accessible measures to help viable facilities maintain operations, retain employees and manage trade disruption that reflect the operating realities of Canada’s forest sector. Second was carefully designed countermeasures, remission processes and import monitoring that protect Canadian producers and supply chains from unintended harm and unfairly priced imports diverted into Canada. They wanted immediate implementation of the Forest Sector Transformation Task Force recommendations, including action on economic fiber access, regulatory efficiency, wildlife resilience, transportation competitiveness and investment in anchor facilities and value added manufacturing. FPAC encouraged stronger domestic demand and market diversification through federal housing, infrastructure and procurement programs that make greater use of Canadian wood and forest products.
The Federal government subsequently announced measures to protect and support Canadian workers and businesses during the current period of uncertainty and volatility, after the efforts to secure a fair and comprehensive trade agreement were not successful. With additional tariffs on U.S. goods, Canada is matching, dollar for dollar, rate for rate, the U.S. decision to impose a 50 percent tariff on $27.6 billion of Canadian goods. In addition, to support Canadian workers and businesses impacted by US tariffs, the government also introduced a $7.5 billion package of new and enhanced measures that deliver fast, simple and agile support to Canadian workers and businesses. The Honourable Melanie Joly, Minister of Industry and Minister Responsible for Canada Economic Development for Quebec Regions said “in a more uncertain world, Canada will continue to invest in our greatest strengths: our workers, our businesses, and our capacity to compete. Today’s new measures will protect jobs, strengthen the industries that drive our economy, and secure the supply chains that underpin our prosperity. Canada will not simply respond to change, we will shape it, growing a stronger economy that delivers opportunity, security and prosperity for Canadians.”
FPAC welcomed the announcement of these measures to support Canadian businesses, employers and communities affected by the tariffs. “We appreciate the government’s quick action to address the serious pressures facing Canadian industries and impacted families,” said Nighbor. Duties and tariffs on billions of dollars’ worth of products now range from 25 percent to 85 percent. The addition of Section 338 tariffs make immediate federal support essential to help keep facilities operating and employees connected to their places of work.” Nighbor also remarked, “no support package can replace reliable access to our largest export market but it is urgently needed in this moment. Canada must continue pressing for the removal of unjustified tariffs and a durable resolution to the softwood lumber dispute while also addressing the regulatory, transportation and competitiveness challenges within our own control.” FPAC noted that new U.S. tariffs not only put Canadian forestry jobs at risk, but they are putting an already weak American economy at greater risk too. By comparison, July numbers show that while housing starts in Canada were down 4 percent, they were down 13 percent in the United States. These tariffs are bad news for the U.S. housing market and for American families.
Canada has also been seeking closer ties with the European Union, as part of its effort to diversify trade and to be less dependent on the U.S. market. Closer co-operation, and even an associate membership in the EU, have been floated. As part of that, Canada has encouraged the EU to ease up on its proposed deforestation rules. Before a Senate national finance committee, representatives from the lumber and steel industries warn that the expansion of overseas market can’t make up for the loss of access to the American market. They indicated that there are limits our country will face in moving exports to other countries. Nighbor noted that it is “not a matter of putting sticks on a boat and sending them somewhere else. It is not quite that easy. While Canadian manufacturers do see Japan, China, South Korea and the EU as places with potential, those markets cannot absorb enough Canadian product to replace American demand. The diversification opportunity, it’s incremental. Not to say it’s not worth doing, but I think we need to be realistic about what the opportunity is. It took us about 50 years to build a billion-dollar business in Japan.” It was noted that further export growth to other markets will require work on building codes, relationships with other governments and local businesses and training builders to use Canadian wood products.
Despite the dominance of the tariff issue, life goes on and other developments continue. In the lead up to the Quebec provincial election, which has just taken place, the Quebec Forest Industry Council (CIFQ) published the priorities for the forest industry for candidates to consider. They invited the political parties to make forests a priority and to bring an ambitious, sustainable and mobilizing forest vision for the province. In the context of increasing international trade tensions, in the face of supply challenges and climate change, and in energy transitions and the diversification of markets, this vision is essential to create the necessary conditions for a stronger sector that is modern, sustainable and competitive. “The next government must be proud and present a clear and ambitious vision for the forest and its forest industry. To take on the challenges of tomorrow, we will have to show some boldness, rethink certain approaches and innovate in our management models. An economic and strategic pillar for Quebec, our sector is at the heart of the national forestry sector and it has become imperative to put in place the conditions to create an industry that is modern, competitive and sustainable,” said Michel Vincent, President of the CIFQ.
To get to where it needs to be, the industry identified four priorities to guide the actions of the next government. They include building sustainable partnerships with the First Nations and modernizing the forestry regime and rethinking the management of the land. “Access to fiber remains the cornerstone of all the forest value chain. It is therefore essential to increase the predictability of access to the resource, to improve the cost competitiveness of supply and to simplify the administrative and regulatory framework applicable to forestry activities. Forest management that is more decentralized and adaptable to regional realities and priorities will also help strengthen the vitality of forest areas,” affirmed Vincent. The other two priorities are to reinforce the competitiveness of the industry and stimulate investments, and to develop the markets and maximize the value of Quebec wood products.
Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. (CMHC) provided a bit of positive analysis on the possible impacts for Canadian lumber producers from the U.S. tariffs. A potential consequence at home if more Canadian wood stays in Canada and builders make more use of it, some types of housing could become significantly cheaper to construct. CMHC suggests that the cost of construction of ground-oriented homes, including detached houses and townhouses, could be as much as 17 percent less in some markets under its modeling. They say that could result in approx. 3.5 percent more ground-oriented housing starts nationally, which is about 4,000 additional homes each year. The finding does not mean tariffs themselves make housing cheaper, but identifies an opportunity Canada could capture if trade disruption leaves more domestic wood available and the construction industry can put it to work.










